My Easter basket was always filled with jellybeans, a chocolate bunny, and marshmallow chicks. As an adult I still can’t make it through the season without buying a package of sugar coated marshmallows. Recently I discovered that I could easily make my own marshmallows at home and decorate them in festive ways for any holiday. Homemade marshmallows have a wonderfully light and fluffy texture that melts in your mouth and a lovely vanilla flavor.  If you prefer, you can even use flavored oils and extracts to make lemon, banana, orange, cherry or even cola-flavored marshmallows.


  • 2 cups yellow sugar*
  • Butter to grease tin foil
  • 1 cup water, divided
  • 3 packages powdered gelatin
  • 1 1/2 cups white granulated sugar
  • 1 cup light corn syrup
  • Pinch of salt
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 96 candy eyes
  • 48 golden orange diamond shaped sprinkes
  • Cookie white icing

Prep Time 45 min

Total Time 2 hr 0 min
Servings 48
In order to make the perfect homemade marshmallows you must have a few specific kitchen tools. A candy thermometer is essential, as you need to monitor the temperature of boiling sugar syrup and pull it off the stove at just the right time. The other piece of equipment is a stand mixer. I’ve burned out motors in hand held mixers making marshmallows, so unless yours is exceptionally powerful, I recommend a stand mixer with a nice big bowl.

If you have those two things, then making marshmallows is really quite easy, and decorating them for Easter is so much fun!

To start, you want to line a 10-inch by 15-inch baking sheet with non-stick or regular tin foil. Butter the foil well and sprinkle it liberally with yellow decorating sugar. * If you can’t find yellow sugar, you can make your own. Just pour white granulated sugar in a large zip-top bag, add a few squirts of yellow food coloring, and shake until the sugar turns yellow.

To make the marshmallows you need to bloom some gelatin. That simply means sprinkling it over some cold water and letting it soften for about 5 minutes. I usually just bloom my gelatin in the bowl of my stand mixer.

Next up, boil the sugar syrup. Start by giving your sugar, corn syrup, water and salt a little gentle stir, then put the lid on the pot, bring it to a boil, remove the lid and just wait until it reaches 240ºF. You don’t have to sit over a hot pot and stir. It’s great!

Once the syrup has reached that temperature, carefully pour it into the bloomed gelatin. Turn your mixer on low, and slowly drizzle the syrup into the bowl. I usually wear oven mitts just in case any of that boiling sugar syrup spatters out of the mixer.

Now all you have to do is turn the mixer up to medium for a minute or two then up to high and walk away for a while. About 10-15 minutes later your marshmallow will be bright white and light and fluffy. You can add some flavoring now. The recipe calls for vanilla, but you can get creative and use any extract or flavored oil you’d like. If you use flavored oils, add about a 1/4 of a teaspoon, and then taste it. Add more if needed. The marshmallow is ready when it has cooled to barely warm.

Pour the marshmallow onto the sugar coated baking pan. I find it very helpful to butter both sides of a rubber spatula or a plastic bench scraper to do this job.

Spread it out as well as you can. I actually put on a pair of food handling gloves, buttered them well, and then used my hands to flatten the marshmallow in the pan.

Sprinkle lots of yellow sugar over the top of the marshmallow and walk away.

About an hour later your marshmallows will be ready to cut using a buttered metal egg cutter. The sides of the marshmallow eggs will be sticky, so roll them in some yellow sugar.

If you’re using a 1 1/2-inch by 2 1/2-inch cutter like I did, you’ll get 48 marshmallows out of a batch, plus lots of scraps to snack on.

Now comes the fun part; you get to decorate those yellow eggs to look like adorable chicks! If you want to keep things simple, attach two candy eyes and one golden orange diamond shaped sprinkle to each egg using Cookie Icing. For a more detailed look, pipe on a cracked egg using more icing.

If you want, you can put the marshmallow chicks on lollipop sticks, just make sure you do it while the icing is still wet, or better yet, before you ice them. If you wait and try to add the stick once the icing has hardened you’ll get cracked eggs.

And they’ll be a huge hit with your friends and family when they discover adorable, delicious marshmallow chicks in their Easter baskets!

via  tablespoon